April 23, 2010

Under the Government's Wing

Handing Charitable Authority to the State

Justin Katz

In a recent iteration of his editor's column for First Things, Joseph Bottum takes up the topic of the branches of religious organizations that reside at the edges of the organized church, itself, what he calls "limicole institutions":

As [Archbishop] Chaput notes, the first leverage typically used is financial. Public bureaucrats and lawmakers pressure Catholic agencies by threatening to withdraw funding or to revoke tax exemptions. And, as a result, Catholic Charities in many jurisdictions end up obliged, for both practical and legal reasons, to hire a majority non-Catholic staff.

Of course, that issue is but one aspect of the larger issue of religious liberty. Over the next decade, this is where the battle of religious liberty will be most visibly fought—in the limicole institutions. And particularly in the Catholic ones, as the most visible and, in bulk, significant. Homosexual activity, contraception, and abortion will be the flashpoints. To quote, again, Archbishop Chaput, "Critics rarely dispute the Church's work fighting injustice, helping community development, or serving persons in need. But that's no longer enough. Now they demand that the Church must submit her identity and mission to the state's promotion of these newly alleged rights—despite the constant Catholic teaching that these behaviors are personal moral tragedies that can lead to deep social injustices."

As I've stated, before, there are two issues, here, the first being the obvious matter of religious liberty and the lines that protect it. The second issue, which is less remarked in this context, is the oppressively broad government that, frankly, many religious people have helped to bring about as they've sought to leverage civic authority as a means of social change and charitable action.

Once it became a matter of law that the government could enforce non-discrimination in employment, it became a matter of political maneuvering to define what constitutes discrimination. It should not surprise religious people that those who find their worldview misguided, even fundamentally offensive, would determine that their religious doctrine violate the law. Similarly, as the government has taken on the role of regulating and funding charitable services — a cause for which religious officials and laypeople continue to advocate — it has gained authority over those who provide such services as a religious mission.

People seem to believe that common sense and reasonable allowances will always be a factor in government action. It's a dubious proposition of itself, but religious citizens, especially, ought to appreciate the problem that their civic opposition believes that common sense and reasonable allowances are subjective, shifting concepts, conveniently tending toward their core beliefs, not ours.

5:44 AM | TrackBack (0)
Comments, although monitored, are not necessarily representative of the views Anchor Rising's contributors or approved by them. We reserve the right to delete or modify comments for any reason.

It is a mistake for a private charity, religious or not, to accept government funding for its programs. Once you do such a deal with the devil you are a hostage.

Posted by: BobN at April 23, 2010 1:48 PM

"Archbishop Chaput, "Critics rarely dispute the Church's work fighting injustice, helping community development, or serving persons in need. But that's no longer enough. Now they demand that the Church must submit her identity and mission to the state's promotion of these newly alleged rights—despite the constant Catholic teaching that these behaviors are personal moral tragedies that can lead to deep social injustices."

Contraception is a personal moral tragedy that can lead to deep social injustice?
Preventing an unwanted pregnancy IMHO is a way to keep women from personal moral tragedy and social injustices.

Posted by: swazool at April 23, 2010 2:44 PM

BobN might be right. With regard to religious charities, it all depends upon who's the devil and who's the hostage.
OldTimeLefty

Posted by: OldTimeLefty at April 23, 2010 5:26 PM

ערב טוב אנשים, אני מאוד רוצה להמליץ לכם על הדברה ביולוגית וריסוס צרעות בעל נסיון של עשרות שנים רבות בענף ההדברת ג וקים , מיגור מזיקים ועוד כל מיני סוגים של חרקים רבים אחרים .

Posted by: הדברה at June 22, 2011 7:25 PM

I simply wanted to compose a small word in order to thank you for those fantastic advice you are giving here. My extensive internet investigation has at the end of the day been rewarded with really good suggestions to go over with my two friends. I 'd say that most of us readers are rather lucky to dwell in a fantastic community with many perfect professionals with great opinions. I feel very privileged to have encountered your web site and look forward to so many more brilliant times reading here. Thanks again for everything.

Posted by: Chang Wingfield at July 12, 2011 10:13 AM

Its such as you learn my mind! You appear to understand so much about this, such as you wrote the e-book in it or something. I think that you simply can do with a few percent to drive the message house a little bit, however instead of that, this is excellent blog. An excellent read. I'll definitely be back. Regards.

Posted by: Allie Tony at October 26, 2011 4:46 AM

I acquired mоrе a nеw challenge оn this weight-loss issue. One issue iѕ that good nutrition is vеry vital while dieting. A big reduction in fast foods, sugary ingredients, fried foods, sweet foods, red meat, and white flour products might be necessary. Having wastes parasites, and poisons may prevent desired goals for fat-loss. While certain drugs for thе short term solve the challenge, the awful side effects will not bе worth it, they uѕually nevеr provide mоrе thаn a short-lived solution. It іѕ a known undeniable fact that 95% of fad diets fail. Thanks fоr sharing your opinions on thiѕ blog site.

Posted by: hoodia at December 1, 2011 12:17 PM

One thing I want to discuss is that weight loss program fast can bе performed by thе appropriate diet and exercise. Ones size not merеlу affects appearance, but аlѕo the entire quality оf life. Self-esteem, melancholy, health risks, and alѕo physical skills аrе afflicted in an increase in weight. It iѕ рosѕіblе to do еvеrуthing right and ѕtill gain. If thіѕ happеnѕ, a problem mаy be thе primary cauѕе. While a lot of food rather than еnоugh exercising are usuаlly guilty, common health concerns аnd key prescriptions can greatly help tо increase size. Many thanks for уour post in thіs article.

Posted by: hoodia diet pills at December 1, 2011 1:03 PM

Thanks fоr the write-up. My spouse and i hаvе always seen that а majority оf people arе desperate to lose weight as they wіѕh to appear slim and attractive. However, thеу dо not continually realize that there аrе mоrе benefits to losing weight in addition. Doctors say thаt fat people experience a variety оf disorders that сan bе directly attributed tо their own excess weight. The great thing іѕ thаt people who're overweight as well аѕ suffering frоm different diseases can hеlр to eliminate thе severity оf the illnesses through losing weight. It іѕ easy tо sеe а constant but identifiable improvement with health while evеn а slight amount of weight reduction is achieved.

Posted by: hoodia diet pills at December 3, 2011 2:46 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?

Important note: The text "http:" cannot appear anywhere in your comment.