April 17, 2010

A Dangerous Fine Line in Blending Public/Private Education

Justin Katz

There are two factors — arguably in opposing ideological directions — in which this news should raise concerns:

A plan to create what could be the first U.S. public charter schools run by a Roman Catholic archdiocese is meeting resistance from those who worry about whether religious messages and icons will really stay out of the classrooms and hallways.

Mayor Greg Ballard says the plan is an innovative way to keep schools open so they can fill the needs of families in the struggling areas surrounding the schools. Archdiocese officials saw an opportunity to keep the schools open despite a growing budget deficit.

Predictably, the national movement to cut churches out of the public square has pounced on the transformation of the schools, asserting doubts that the wicked religious folks will follow through on their vows to end religious classes and remove religious symbols and literature from the premises. With regard to their activism, I can only opine that such measures should not be a national issue, but a state-by-state issue.

But with regard to their preferred policy, I find myself in general agreement. What's the point of non-Catholic Catholic schools? The Church should be extremely wary of dabbling in waters in which secular tides prove again and again to suffocate the missions of organizations. Religious organizations should be resisting the trend to make them subcontractors to the Great Benevolent Charity and Bureaucracy that the government is becoming.

In the case of schools, they should be advocating for school choice and vouchers that allow students to use money allocated for their educations toward their preferred institutions — regardless of private, public, and religious status. That's how "separation of church and state" ought to function: with the separation being the individual citizen who operates in both spheres.

Comments, although monitored, are not necessarily representative of the views Anchor Rising's contributors or approved by them. We reserve the right to delete or modify comments for any reason.

Maybe the outcry over vouchers would be lessened if the Catholic Church renamed its schools? How does Bishop Hendricken Madrassa sound?

Posted by: chuckR at April 17, 2010 12:12 PM

Chuck may not know how right he is. In Minneapolis there is a charter school that actually is a madrassa run by extremist Muslims. Yes, American tax dollars are funding a school that produces Nidal Hasans and al-Qaeda terrorists right here on our own soil.

Posted by: BobN at April 17, 2010 1:44 PM

If you mean the Tarek Ibn Ziad Academy (TIZA) you forgot to mention that the ACLU is bringing suit against them “Taxpayer money is being used to promote religion, in violation of the Constitution’s Establishment clause in the First Amendment.” your silence regarding the ACLU action here speaks volumes as typically, you ignore the good works of the ACLU when they run contrary to your preconceptions and prejudices.

You might also want to say a word or two about the director of Minnesota’s Aki/Heart of the Earth School, Joel Pourier who appeared in court on charges of embezzling $1.38 million from the school for American Indian children and spending it on houses, cars and nights at strip clubs. Since tax dollars are going to pay for junkets by directors of our charter schools

You might conclude with, "Yes, American tax dollars are funding a school headed by two bit Bernie Madoffs and immoral charlatans right here on our own soil."


Posted by: OldTimeLefty at April 18, 2010 10:25 AM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Important note: The text "http:" cannot appear anywhere in your comment.