Print
Return to online version

December 17, 2007

Incentive to Produce

Justin Katz

This sort of thing shouldn't be anywhere near the chopping block:

Investors in six start-ups are getting a lucrative reward for betting on local entrepreneurs, part of a new and costly state effort to grow local companies.

Last night, the state Economic Development Corporation approved the first applications for the Innovation Tax Credit. The companies may now offer investors a credit of up to $100,000 off their individual state income-tax bill in return for their investments. ...

But it is being unveiled at a time of alarming fiscal challenges for the state, as the legislature struggles to close a projected $450-million budget deficit.

Those strains have prompted cuts in public spending, including the recent layoff of more than 100 state workers and sharp reductions in support for social-service agencies.

The imbalance has provoked demands from advocates for the poor that many state tax credits, such as those given to the film industry and developers renovating historic buildings, be scaled back or eliminated. ...

Participating companies can receive a maximum of $100,000 in tax credits to bestow on investors, distribute to employees or hand over to a new executive as a signing bonus. (The credits can be shared by up to 10 individuals. Unlike other state programs, they cannot be sold.)

The program offers investors a 50-percent credit on their investment. For example, an investor who puts $100,000 into one of the companies could end up paying $50,000 less on his state income tax bill.

The six applicants approved last night received $100,000 apiece in credits. Under the 2006 law, the EDC can dole out $2 million every two years, leaving another $1.4 million available this period. The legislation expires in 2016.

Add some strings, if you want. Require, for example, a time commitment to the state. Heck, require some percentage of residency. But these back-door balms are crucial to take the sting out of Rhode Island's otherwise unattractive business climate and local infrastructure.

Comments

"sharp reductions in support for social-service agencies."

... when did that happen?

Posted by: Monique at December 17, 2007 1:38 PM

Saul Kaplan, Director of Economic Development Corporation (EDC), Carcieri’s top economic development adviser

“Many of our incentive programs are outdated,” Kaplan said in a statement.

But in an interview yesterday, he argued that the deficit has made economic development initiatives — including tax credits — particularly vital.

“This is exactly the time we should be putting together a bold agenda for our economy,” Kaplan said. “We have to reposition our economy.

“We’re trying to raise the average wage in the state,” Kaplan said. “Our strategy is focused on how to grow these sectors.

“We need to create a more entrepreneurial culture here in Rhode Island,” he said.

To be eligible, businesses must be in high-wage industries, such as biotechnology, information technology, financial services or marine and defense manufacturing. Applicants must have revenue of less than $1 million.

I’m all for creating jobs in the state but I keep hearing the buzz words “high-wage” or “high-paying” and realize the economy is made up of all wage groups and trades. If taxes are going to be used to help jump start RI’s economy then it should be applied equally to all business and trade sectors not just an elite few.

The program does not come cheap to taxpayers, who could be asked to compensate for the lost revenue.

According to the article statement above, Mr. Sal Kaplan feels Rhode Island tax payers can afford the $450 million budget deficit plus his $600,000.00 in tax credits.

Posted by: Ken at December 17, 2007 4:30 PM