Print
Return to online version

December 3, 2010

Land and Money

Justin Katz

Last month, Marc noted that the Providence Journal editors' article pointing out that some relatively conservative states lead the nation in per-capita stimulus funding conveniently sliced the data. As Marc showed, the top 10 states by dollar amount were not all that surprising. As he also showed, funding per square mile shifted the list to mainly blue (and small) states.

A recent letter to the editor by Ernie Rabideau, of Bristol, makes the same point from another direction:

Note that five of the top seven by low population match five of the top seven by stimulus funding per capita, including all of the top four. If you further consider states with the lowest population densities, six of the top seven are matches with the top funding recipients per capita. This is because an equivalent bridge, road or utility system in Alaska or Montana costs more per capita than one in say, California, because of its cost being divided by a much lower number of people.

As an extreme example, a construction expenditure in Wyoming actually costs over 68 times more per capita than the same one in California. Sure, fewer people may need fewer roads and bridges, but roads in big sparsely populated states must be longer to connect population centers, and basic construction costs in cold and/or mountainous locations are generally higher than in warm flat ones. I suppose if we want to balance per- capita spending by state, we don’t have to connect the cities and towns in the rural west, or Vermont, with safe roads and bridges; but there are many benefits to our entire country when we do.

Comments

Hey i just visited your site for the first time and i really liked it, i bookmarked it and will be back :D

Posted by: Richard Wildye at June 10, 2011 3:28 PM

Thanks for your text. I would like to say that the health insurance brokerage service also utilizes the benefit of the coordinators of a group insurance policies. The health insurance broker is given a directory of benefits sought by someone or a group coordinator. Exactly what a broker may is hunt for individuals as well as coordinators which usually best complement those desires. Then he shows his advice and if the two of you agree, the particular broker formulates a contract between the two parties.

Posted by: Fallon Loza at May 18, 2012 7:14 AM