Print
Return to online version

November 26, 2009

Climazdat

Justin Katz

In a sense, it oughtn't be surprising, but it does seem as if the degree is notching up, and each step is shocking: Even some among the better informed among the folks with whom I interact on a daily basis (who are, to be sure, less well informed than even the most disengaged among readers of online punditry) remain unaware of this story:

Some of the world’s top climate scientists have been accused of manipulating data on global warming after hundreds of private emails were stolen by hackers and published online.

The material was taken from servers at the University of East Anglia's Climatic Research Unit — a world-renowned climate change research centre — before it was published on websites run by climate change sceptics.

It has been claimed that the emails show that scientists manipulated data to bolster their argument that global warming is genuine and is being caused by human actions.

Go to just about any right-of-center Web site with a national or international focus, and you'll find the details (which, of course, most of you have already seen). James Delingpole provides a good starting point. Mark Steyn notes the expanding scope.

Most striking, though, is this reader email, sent to Instapundit Glenn Reynolds (link added):

I now have a sense of what it was like living under Communism in Eastern Europe. The state-owned (in our case, establishment) press won’t report on reality so people had to turn to Samizdat to learn what’s actually happening in their world. It’s rather amazing. Also, having an Army of Davids go through these emails will pay dividends for years.

It may be a tired formulation, but you can just imagine if there were even hints of this scale of controversy on an issue with which mainstreamers held an ideologically opposing view.

Comments

I have been watching for some reportage of the eamails "libereated" from East Anglia University. I have seen little other than that it was a a "tempest in a teapot".

Posted by: Warrington Faust at November 27, 2009 9:45 AM

I have at last found a newspaper willing to give some real time to the University of East Anglia e-mails. That is the Economist. Although they espouse a belief in "global warming" they caution against failing to re-examine the issue:

http://www.economist.com/opinion/displayStory.cfm?story_id=14966227&source=hptextfeature

Posted by: Warrington Faust at November 28, 2009 12:06 PM